Have you ever been to Groton, Connecticut? If not, you’re missing out on one of the sweetest spots in town – Mystic Sweet Shop! This charming little shop has been a staple in the community since 1997, and let me tell you, they have some of the most delicious treats you’ll ever taste. From homemade ice cream to hand-painted chocolates, Mystic Sweet Shop is a haven for anyone with a sweet tooth.

Owned by the talented Rita Lara, this shop is truly a labor of love. Rita puts her heart and soul into creating the most delectable ice cream, chocolates, fudges, candies, truffles, and gelato. And if you’re a fan of the classics, you’ll be delighted to know that they also sell olde-timey candies that will transport you back in time.

One thing that sets Mystic Sweet Shop apart from other sweet shops is their specialty in hand-painted and custom painted chocolates. These little works of art not only taste amazing but also look like a masterpiece. It’s no wonder that this shop has received rave reviews for their chocolates – they truly are something special.

Located in a high rent tourist district in downtown Mystic, you can expect that Mystic Sweet Shop is always bustling with both locals and tourists. But don’t worry, you won’t have to battle through crowds to get your hands on their treats. The amazing customer service here ensures that everyone is served with a smile and doesn’t leave empty-handed.

If you’re looking for a gift that will truly impress, Mystic Sweet Shop has you covered. They offer gift bags for all occasions, including unique ones like dog sitters and cat sitters. It’s those little touches that showcase just how much thought and care goes into everything they do.

Now that you have a taste of what Mystic Sweet Shop has to offer, stay tuned for our upcoming article where we’ll dive even deeper into this sweet haven. Trust me, you won’t want to miss it!

Mystic Sweets & Ice Cream Shoppe

Located in Groton, Connecticut, Mystic Sweet Shop has been delighting visitors since 1997 with its wide array of homemade treats. Owned by the talented Rita Lara, the shop is known for its delicious ice cream, chocolates, fudges, candies, truffles, gelato, and more. With its specialization in hand-painted and custom painted chocolates, Mystic Sweet Shop has carved a niche for itself in the confectionery world.

Mystic Sweets Ice Cream Shoppe

History and Location

Mystic Sweet Shop finds its home in the charming town of Groton, Connecticut. Nestled in a high rent tourist district in downtown Mystic, the shop enjoys a prime location that attracts both locals and visitors alike. Since its opening in 1997, Mystic Sweet Shop has become a beloved destination for sweet-toothed individuals craving quality and unique treats.

Owner and Specialties

At the heart of Mystic Sweet Shop’s success is its owner, Rita Lara. Rita’s passion for confectionery shines through in her handmade creations. With years of experience and expertise in ice cream-making and chocolate-making, she brings her own unique touch to every sweet treat at the shop.

One of the highlights of Mystic Sweet Shop’s offerings is its variety of homemade ice cream flavors. From classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to innovative creations like salted caramel and lavender honey, there is a flavor to satisfy every palate. Each batch of ice cream is carefully crafted to ensure a rich and creamy texture that keeps customers coming back for more.

In addition to their delectable ice cream, Mystic Sweet Shop is renowned for its hand-painted and custom painted chocolates. With intricate designs and a stunning attention to detail, these chocolates are not only a treat for the taste buds but also a feast for the eyes. Each box of chocolates carries the mark of Rita’s artistry and her commitment to creating a truly special experience for her customers.

Mystic Sweets Ice Cream Shoppe

Unique Offerings

Mystic Sweet Shop also prides itself on offering a selection of olde-timey candies, evoking a sense of nostalgia and taking customers on a trip down memory lane. From jawbreakers to licorice, customers can find their favorite childhood candies and relive the joy of simpler times.

However, the star of the show at Mystic Sweet Shop is their signature treat: Penuche. This fudge-like candy, made from brown sugar, butter, and milk, is a local favorite that keeps customers coming back for more. With its rich and creamy texture, Penuche has become synonymous with the sweet indulgence that Mystic Sweet Shop represents.

Mystic Sweet Shop has also received many positive reviews for its chocolates. Customers rave about the smoothness, richness, and pure bliss that each bite delivers. Whether it’s a gift for a loved one or a personal indulgence, these chocolates are sure to satisfy even the most discerning chocolate lover.

Mystic Sweets Ice Cream Shoppe

Expertise and Recognition

Behind the scenes, Rita Lara brings her expertise and passion to every aspect of Mystic Sweet Shop’s offerings. With her extensive knowledge of ice cream-making and chocolate-making, she ensures that every treat leaving the shop is of the highest quality.

The positive reviews that Mystic Sweet Shop has garnered over the years serve as testament to the dedication and skill that goes into each creation. Customers appreciate the attention to detail, the use of quality ingredients, and the overall experience that Mystic Sweet Shop provides. It is no wonder that it has become a go-to destination for those seeking a truly exceptional sweet treat.

In recent times, Mystic Sweet Shop has seen the need for differentiation from another ice cream shop in the area. As a result, the shop recently changed its store name, ensuring that customers can easily distinguish between the two establishments. This change in name reflects Mystic Sweet Shop’s dedication to providing a unique experience and its commitment to continuously evolving and improving.

Mystic Sweets Ice Cream Shoppe

Gift Options

Mystic Sweet Shop understands the importance of gift-giving and offers a range of gift bags for various occasions. Whether it’s a birthday, anniversary, or a simple token of appreciation, customers can find the perfect gift to make their loved ones feel special. From beautifully packaged boxes of chocolates to curated selections of candies and fudges, each gift bag is thoughtfully prepared to bring joy to both the giver and the receiver.

Mystic Sweet Shop even goes a step further by offering gift bags specifically designed for dog sitters and cat sitters. These unique gifts are a wonderful way to express gratitude to those who care for our furry friends when we are away. Filled with treats that both pets and their caretakers can enjoy, these gift bags have become a cherished offering at Mystic Sweet Shop.

Mystic Sweets Ice Cream Shoppe


Mystic Sweet Shop’s history in Groton, Connecticut, spans over two decades, and its reputation as a purveyor of delectable treats is well-deserved. With owner Rita Lara at the helm, the shop has become a beloved destination for those seeking extraordinary ice cream, chocolates, fudges, and candies.

From the moment you step into Mystic Sweet Shop, you are greeted with warmth and the aroma of freshly made treats. With its wide selection of ice cream flavors, including signature creations and classic favorites, there is something for everyone.

The hand-painted and custom painted chocolates are a true work of art that showcases Rita’s craftsmanship and attention to detail. Each bite is a sensory experience that transports you to a world of pure indulgence.

Mystic Sweet Shop’s commitment to excellence has not gone unnoticed. With positive reviews affirming their dedication to quality and an ever-evolving approach, the shop continues to delight and surprise customers with its culinary delights.

Whether you are in search of a sweet treat for yourself, a gift for a loved one, or simply a memorable experience, Mystic Sweet Shop offers it all. Step through its doors, and you will be welcomed into a world of sweetness and smiles that will leave you wanting more.

By mystictastebuds

Hello, I'm mystictastebuds, the author behind Mystic Taste Buds. Welcome to my website, Your Premier Source For The Mystic Dining Experience. As a lover of good food and intriguing flavors, I provide detailed reviews of restaurants in the Mystic CT area. I explore the unique culinary offerings and capture the essence of each dining experience. Additionally, I curate a selection of home barware items inspired by the coastal charm of Mystic CT and the marvelous restaurants I visit. Join me as I embark on a journey to discover the hidden gems and savor the culinary delights that Mystic has to offer.